How much do genetics matter?

[BendtheBar]

Advanced Muscle Science: How much do genetics matter?

How much do genetics matter?
Phil Heath Wannabe

People always ask how much genetics really matter when it comes to building muscle. Scientifically that has always been somewhat hard to answer, simply because it's difficult to quantify what factors account for certain %'s of muscle growth. At the same time, we know they clearly matter otherwise everyone would walk around looking like Mr. Olympia Champ Phil Heath. We also all know a guy who eats, and trains like shit, but still looks better and lifts more than 99% of those in the gym. So how is that possible?

In late 2010 one of the more interesting studies on genetics and muscle growth was published in the Journal of Applied Physiology. This was a great study because they wanted to determine the genetic differences between high responders and low responders to strength training. In fact I thought it was somewhat ground breaking to a degree, and posted it on the forums shortly after it was e-published.

Mir'in my miRNA's?

MicroRNA's or miRNA's are approximately 22 short nucleotide ribonucleic acids. MicroRNA's essentially control the expression of messenger RNA's, which essentially tell a cell what to do (protein synthesis). What?! In simpler terms, MicroRNA's regulate gene expression. Why do we care? Well this research did something interesting. They took 56 men between the ages of 18 and 30 and put them through 12 weeks of resistance training that included weight training 5 days per week. The study controls were great as well and they monitored everything including:

Diet
Training Status
Compliance
Initial Body Mass

After the training they split the 56 men up. They found the top 15-20% responders based on cross sectional muscle fiber increases (and vice versa for low responders). They took these two groups (high and low responders), and further analyzed them by completing 1 rep maxes in the leg press, knee extension, and hamstring curls. This resulted in the final two groups of 8-9 men that they dubbed High and Low responders.

High responders gained almost 4 times the amount of lean body mass in the same training period (remember diets & training were controlled). Over the twelve weeks it resulted in approximately 10lbs of lean body mass gain in the high responder group compared to only ~2.4lbs in the low responder group. Almost a difference of 8lbs! Clearly there must be a genetic influence involved.

The more important part of this study was their analysis of muscle biopsies, which included differences in miRNA abundance between each group. They measured 21 different miRNA's in each group. Only four were found to be statistically different in each group:

miR-378 - positive correlation to muscle mass gains, and down-regulated in low responders
miR-29a & miR26a - down-regulated in low responders, unchanged in high responders
miR-451 - up-regulated in low responders

With this information we clearly have some "genetic targets" that we may be able to alter by supplementation. What exactly that is, we do not know yet. Much of the genetic research, particularly on microRNA's, is still in it's infancy. Still this leaves us with with some insight. We know that there is quite the disparity between the genetically gifted and the genetically inferior. Most of the 56 men fell somewhere in the middle in terms of lean body mass gain. So overall, even if you're in the bottom 15-20%, we know you can still achieve some level of personal success with weight training and dieting correctly.

[Off Road]

We know that there is quite the disparity between the genetically gifted and the genetically inferior.

even if you're in the bottom 15-20%, we know you can still achieve some level of personal success with weight training and dieting correctly.

EVERYBODY can make progress in strength and muscle size. Some guys will just do it quicker and take it farther. This is not groundbreaking news and I'm still baffled at why some still cannot grasp this simple concept.

You usually have the more genetically gifted guys shouting, "Genetics are just an excuse for not training hard or eating enough." It is impossible for them to understand the struggles of others. Then you have the genetically disadvantaged crying, "My genetics won't allow me to get anywhere no matter how hard I try." And yes, some do use it as an excuse because they know how hard they'll actually have to work to see small gains. I have the advantage of being somewhere in the middle and seeing both sides.

If they do find a way to manipulate MicroRNA through supplementation, it will be interesting to see if good responders will still out-perfrom the low responders thus still having the disparity? Or will the playing field even out because of limitations of the system? Somebody much more advanced in science could probably help with that question.

[BendtheBar]

Originally Posted by Off Road

"My genetics won't allow me to get anywhere no matter how hard I try."

I'd love to have a year with a group of guys like this to see what I could do. If they listened to me.

[moeheep]

You can sign me up Steve !

[Off Road]

Originally Posted by BendtheBar

I'd love to have a year with a group of guys like this to see what I could do. If they listened to me.

A whole year would be nice because what usually happens is they will only last a few months. I've helped several, but as soon as they start to make progress they switch back to their old way of training. It's as if they think all they had to do was get the ball rolling and then they could just do whatever they wanted after that. And they all think they are more advanced than they actually are.

[BendtheBar]

Originally Posted by moeheep

You can sign me up Steve !

I'd love to help. We all would love to help for that matter.

But it won't be easy

If you do want us to comb through what you're doing and make some suggestions, perhaps you can get a thread going with where you are at.

[Kuytrider]

Originally Posted by Off Road

And they all think they are more advanced than they actually are.

I was most certainly in that group. Seeing the weights lifted here opened my eyes.

I also have average genetics at best so I'm quitting training and going out to shout 'steroids' at anyone bigger and stronger than me