|02-28-2010, 07:26 PM||#1|
Join Date: Feb 2010
Contradictions in bodybuilding-ology
As I've learned more and more, I've learned that I have more to learn, and moreover, I realized that that which I have learned may or may not be right.
It seems that for some bodybuilders a lot of the contratictions you hear out there are moot...because either their natural genetics or goals or something allow them to be less concerned with the OC nature of contemporary thinking. But when you get into it and really dig into the idea of success, and the OC follows...well...how can one be OC when there are two conflicting dogmas that are both "well established", "proven", methods for success. I know that some contradictions can be considered logically (though logical idealogy isn't always in sync) and I know that some have been theoretically "proven" one way or another (though "proof" is pretty hard to swallow when it's always hearsay unless you did the study yourself) but in some ways, these contradictions are inevitable because the reality is that bodybuilding, although based on science, is not simply math.
So this thread is to list and discuss contradictions in bodybuilding theories that we've all heard.
Here are a few I came up with off the top of my head. This is not exhaustive of even what I've heard/studied, so as I think of more I'll add them.
Eat X grams of protein per bodyweight -vs- Don't eat that much protien you can't process it
High reps help you build muscle -vs.- High reps don't help you build muscle
Do cardio -vs.- Don't do cardio
Do deadlifts -vs.- Never do deadlifts
Drink a Gallon of water a day -vs.- don't drink a gallon of water a day
Eat 6 times a day -vs.- It doesn't matter, eat once a day for all it matters
Always do post workout sugar -vs.- Don't do post workout sugar
Workout each muscle once a week -vss- Workout each muscle twice (or more) a week
Milk=bad -vs.- Milk=good
Use artficial sweeteners -vs.- Don't use artificial sweeteners
What other contradicitons have you heard, what do you believe, what arguments have you heard/learned for what side, what studies have shown what, etc., etc...?
Last edited by folkprophet; 03-01-2010 at 01:34 PM. Reason: typo
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|