Muscle and Brawn Forums

Muscle and Brawn Forums (
-   General Fitness & Health (
-   -   Anyone Else HATE Collars? (

SaxonViolence 04-28-2013 11:14 AM

Anyone Else HATE Collars?
Thirty years ago, I was doing 20 Rep Squats in my Gym.

For once I was making great gains.

10 more Pounds was going on the Bar every week.

I was beginning to think that I might get to the Magical Weight of 405 X 20 Before I hit a Plateau...

And why, O my Friends, is 405 Pounds a "Magic Weight"?

Because it is an Olympic Bar with 4 45 Pound Plates on either side.

Then I came into the Gym one day, and some Evil Force had messed with my Good Vibes by the most effective subtle means immaginable.

There was a Big Sign saying:

"Collars Must Be Used At All Times When Squatting".

"What is that about?" I asked my Coach—who was half-owner.

"I don't know—Some Wild-Hair that Bud got stuck in his Craw."

Damn, Damn, Tripple Damn!!!

Obviously, from the Phrasing, my Coach didn't feel strongly about the Rule...

But neither was he going to countermand his Partner and get in a Hissing Contest over something he felt was of no Importance...

Now obviously, at some point—as the weight grows great enough to seriously bend the bar, collars become Prudent—and a bit later, Essential.

In the Squat, 405 Ain't it.

495 Ain't it.

Depending on one's style585 may not quite be "It".

I have Never seen someone fail at a Squat in the Gym in such a way that the Bar tips precipitously enough to one side to Dump Plates...

Or to be Prevented from such an action by a Collar.

Certainly, it is Possible—And I will gladly Accept the Risk, whatever it may be, given the freedom to choose.

Collared Plates don't tinkle Merrily and "Sing" to me.

The Thrice-Damned contraptions change the Harmonics and Feel of the Weight...

And I HATE them.

My dislike of Collars grows every time I think about them—for Squats...

They are quite handy when deadlifting—particularly for reps...

In fact, my Loathing for Collared Squats has grown to the place, that in a Gym that didn't Require them...

My own self-imposed Weight Threshold for when I would Voluntarily use them has gone up about 180 Pounds—Just Because.

I HATE Collars.

Anyone else?

Saxon Violence

5kgLifter 04-28-2013 11:18 AM

Nope, I have no issues with collars; if I'm doing Oly style, at home, the barbell has no spinning compartments at all, so I just place the collars a smidgen away from the plates, hey presto! clanking and spinning away...simple!

BendtheBar 04-28-2013 11:18 AM

I am anal about collars. I use spring locks on everything. Seen too many people lean and dump on tough lifts.

So I am the anti-you. I would never take the risk of a collar-less bar.

Off Road 04-28-2013 11:21 AM

Collars or clips don't bother me in the slightest.

Hunterace 04-28-2013 11:22 AM

2 seconds for safety, doesn't bother me one bit!

SCStrong 04-28-2013 11:25 AM

I like em ( except on solo bench efforts) I have actually had weight slip during a squat andthe collars probably saved me from major injury.

Soldier 04-28-2013 11:28 AM

If I put a plate on the bar, I hold it on with a collar. Sorry bro.

I also use additional collars to hold my chains, so I often use 4 collars on a single bar.

Boom 04-28-2013 12:08 PM

I can't imagine having so much hate towards something so trivial...

EliteDreams 04-28-2013 12:17 PM

While I always use collars on my money sets (cant be bothered with most warm ups) I've seen many, not all, Oly lifters not use collars. Wonder why?

5kgLifter 04-28-2013 12:35 PM

The one lift I don't normally worry about them on is the deadlift, unless I'm doing it for lots of reps in which case they help at least keep the load closer together, otherwise they slip further apart and eventually unbalance the barbell as well.

First time I tried doing an oly lift, C&J, with my barbell, I got a nasty shock as the spinlocks clamped whilst the hands and arms were rotating under the barbell; didn't make that mistake twice. Using a small space to maintain the spin between [plates and spinlocks, seems to work fine though, I get the best of both worlds, safety and spinning plates.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:04 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.