Many years ago, a man with a well-developed musculature was rare, primarily because the number of those engage in strength and muscle building activities was small. However, as the population sample of trainees grew through the years, so did the number of well-developed men. It was assumed that there were "good physiques" on the scene because of modernization of training techniques, nutritional manipulation and hormonal experimentation. The truth, though, is that the relative proportion of extremely well-developed physiques is almost the same as it was 25 or 30 years ago. However, the absolute number has increased due to the explosion in the number of individuals now involved in weight training.
Although many new theories of training have been propagated as an explanation for the supposedly sudden improvement of the "average" physique, the truth about strength training has not changed - one must work very hard on a number of basic exercises which stimulate the major muscular structures of the body . . . eat sensibly . . . get adequate rest . . . and remain motivated to train in progressive and productive manner.
However, if you have bought the notion that there has, in fact, been a major change in human physiology, which explains the efficacy of the "new and improved" training programs, you probably copy the leading lights of the sport and do the exercises they do . . . and in the manner in which these stars do them.
Although many exercises are dangerous if performed in a competitive manner, the bench press is perhaps the most dangerous. The bench press? One immediately thinks of a missed squat pinning a lifter to a platform or tearing his quadriceps muscle, causing him to fall pitifully to the floor. Likewise, an errant deadlift can translate into a crippling lower back injury or a hideously deformed biceps tear that rolls up to its origin in the shoulder region. But other than stupidly attempting a maximum single without spotters or dropping the bar on your neck or chest, what orthopedic dangers are presented by this very popular and universally done lift? Dangers that are insidious and long-lasting!
The bench press can be a very productive exercise. Plus, it's a basic, easy-to-learn movement that can be done with a minimum of equipment. If trained in a progressive and productive manner, quite a bit of weight can be used and increases in lean upper body muscle mass can be attained. Unfortunately, if done improperly, it can lead to lumbar spine damage, lesions of the lower back musculature and upper extremity degeneration.
Because competitive powerlifters utilize more weight in this movement than any other group of athletes, it's natural to copy these individuals. It must be realized that the sport of powerlifting requires the development of a number of specific skills, and bench pressing is one of them. Bear in mind, too, that if one is attempting to lift a maximal single repetition, everything is done to make the lift as "easy" as possible. For example, one wants to position his body so that the bar is moved through the shortest range of motion possible; one wants to move the bar in a manner that engages as many of the involved muscle groups as possible; one wants to stabilize the body to remove any unnecessary movement that could detract from the effort that goes into the actual bench press movement.
The competitive lifter has developed a bench pressing style that accomplishes all of the aforementioned, but this does not mean that the bodybuilder, football player or interested trainee should to emulate the powerlifter's style - even they are also interested in lifting as much weight as possible in this exercise.
It has long become acceptable to bench press with the feet planted firmly on the floor and the buttocks and shoulders anchored to the bench top - as is required by powerlifting regulations - and the back held in a high arch. This position makes it difficult, if not impossible, to roll off the bench during the lift, eliminates "body cheat" which can distort one's demonstrated power and lead to possible injury of the spine or upper extremities, shortens the distance that the bar must be moved as it travels from the chest to the lockout position, and establishes an acceptable standard by which meaningful comparisons of performance can be made.
On the other hand, the disadvantages of this position are many: Most athletes involved in powerlifting, bodybuilding, football and other "heavy" athletics do not have the flexibility that is commensurate with their strength and/or muscular mass. Even the exceptional athlete who takes the time to develop extreme ranges of flexibility does so under loads consisting of bodyweight or partial bodyweight. However, when one assumes the arched position on the bench, digs in and sets his body rigidly in place, takes control of the weight, lowers it to the chest and then drives it upward, there is not only increased compressive force on the musculature of the lumbar spine but a certain amount of jamming or sudden compression on the facets - the actual joints of the vertebrae that interface with one another.
The facets are arthroidal joints that have a synovial lining - which when irritated will secrete a surplus of synovial fluid. Extreme arching during the performance of the bench press - especially over a period of time - may lead to chronic irritation of the synovial membranes with inflammation, fluid secretions and discomfort. Moreover, if there is activation of the body's natural defense mechanism, the result will be protective muscle spasms in the area - forcing the lifter to suffer chronic lower back pain, limited ranges of motion and an inability to do any lower back or hip work - all as a result of their bench pressing technique.
If one competes, he attempts to assume this hyperlordotic, or highly arched, position to shorten the stroke of the upper arm movement, and allow the upper extremity to articulate at the shoulder in a way which simulates a decline bench press. This is, for most individuals, the strongest position from which to bench press.
Yet the prolonged execution of this practice definitely leads to injury. And as far as I'm concerned, it's unforgivable to lose training time - especially if it cuts into the more important squat and deadlift work - as a direct result of your benching work. How does one get around this? The solution is simple.
Most individuals have been instructed to keep their feet on the floor during the bench press. In fact, in competition they cannot move their feet as this guarantees forfeiture of the lift. However, to maximize orthopedic safety - especially for young athletes who have active growth plates in the spine - I would like to suggest that the best way to bench press is with a flat back . . . one in which the forward facing curve in the lumber spine is minimized as much as possible. This can best be accomplished by placing the feet on the bench top or footstools eight to 10 inches in height placed adjacent to the bench. These stools or boxes will increase lateral stability if one uses a bench which is less than 30 centimeters in width, which is required for competition. Either position - with the heels and soles on the bench or boxes, will flatten the curve in the lumbar spine, thereby removing compression between the vertebrae and almost eliminating the possibility of facet impingement.
The bench press is a fine upper body developer and heavily relied upon by the strength community - but it should be done as safely as possible. I would encourage all lifters, especially those with a history of lower back discomfort, to bench press with a flat or unarched back in training. The last four weeks prior to a scheduled competition I would assume the competitive posture to adequately practice the skill of bench pressing a relatively heavy weight as one would in a contest. One of the advantages of this strategy is that the bench-pressing muscles will have become quite a bit stronger relative to the results you would have received with conventional form,and it will quickly relate to the competitive lift within the four-week preparation period.
High school and college coaches have no business instructing their football players to bench press with a high arch, nor should bodybuilders adopt this style. Yes, it may initially yield a higher bench press, but at what price? You are much better off utilizing a style where your feet are placed on the bench or on boxes, keeping your back as flat as possible and allowing no body movement other than that in the arms and forearms. In the long run this will prove safer, more productive, and result in a lower incidence of injury.
Views 1058 Comments 4
|09-26-2013, 11:55 AM||#2|
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: South Wales - UK
Training Exp: 3-4 years
Training Type: Fullbody
Nice post Steve.
I think if you are training the bench press for a huge 1 rep total then as long as you are training the other muscles supporting you in the lift then if you are sensible you should remain relitively injury free.
If you just try to emulate PL'ers and suddenly start changing the way you do things then you will run in to trouble.
Your style of lifting, technique etc etc should adapt with you over time, in accordance with your goals.
I doubt there is a universal 'best' way.. Although i am sure there are lots of universally accepted 'wrong' ways to lift!
|09-26-2013, 01:03 PM||#3|
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Richmond, VA
Training Exp: 4 years
Training Type: Powerlifting
Fav Exercise: Squat
Fav Supp: Food
Hey Carl! Nice to hear from you!
As to the article, I think it is interesting, but isn't very clear in a couple ways that are pretty crucial in my opinion. He doesn't ever really describe what is an "extreme" or "high" arch. Is there a less extreme arch that is more acceptable for example?
Also, he says nothing of your shoulders which can flat out get ground to dust by flat back benching, especially if you have longish arms or a thinnish chest relative to your arms.
In my experience, I got a shoulder impingment benching flat backed, and I could not even bench at all now without at least some sort of arch.
That said, I do sometimes have back spasms or get back pain from benching so that is a bit unsettling after having read this.
He mentions a way around this by flat benching and only going "extreme" in the last four weeks before a competition, but I am a little skeptical of that as in my opinion you have to practice how you will compete or your competition won't go very well. Trying to relearn your form, with presumably heavier weights, in the last few weeks of your run up to a competition a bit dubious to me.
In my case, I have lessened my arch for normal training and I also have noticed the more I practice the position, the easier it gets over time. I will be curious to see if the occasional low back aches or spasms lessens over time or increases.
I am Anton Zdravko Martin!
Best meet lifts: Sq 150 Kg (330 lb), Bench 120 Kg (264), DL 160 (352) @89 Kg (197)
Best gym lifts: Sq 375, Bench 280 (pause), DL 385 @205 or less
Goals: 3/4/5 while healthy and fit
"Hack away at anything which isn't essential. Do what you love, and do it often." Fazc.
"Everything competes for recovery so more assistance is not always the best idea." miked96
"Squat:15 sets of 3 with 150Kg
Deadlift:15 sets of 3 with 150Kg
It's not rocket science." Big Swede
|09-27-2013, 02:27 AM||#4|
Join Date: Mar 2011
Training Exp: 30+
Training Type: Other
Fav Exercise: Anything overhead
Fav Supp: Creatine. C'est tout.
230 strict press @ 220; bodyweight+187 X 4 dips @ 180; 403 front squat @ 210; 10 000 push-ups.
Ignoring irrelevant credentials since I was 17.
|09-27-2013, 05:11 AM||#5|
Join Date: Feb 2013
Training Type: Powerbuilding
Fav Exercise: clean & press
I can't bench weight for shit, lol, and have very little experience lifting, but for what it's worth, a small arch (with tight upper back) works best for me, is what I've found so far.
Tried the extreme version (because I can do it, and because "big names" do it - or so I thought), and have sometimes done some flat back benching as well. Legs in various positions too.
Er, but that's just me.
42yo, 6', ~92kg
|Dr. Ken Leistner Appreciation Thread||gothamsreckoning||Appreciation Threads||7||04-06-2013 11:05 AM|
|Back arch, what degree?||5kgLifter||Powerlifting & Strength Training||1||06-22-2012 11:43 AM|
|Nutrition by Ken Leistner||BendtheBar||Articles||3||10-24-2011 09:43 AM|
|Knee ache during and after squatting||strkout35||General Board||10||05-30-2010 10:44 AM|
|Dr. Ken Leistner on John Grimek||BendtheBar||Powerlifting & Strength Training||1||10-17-2009 10:28 AM|
|Article Tools||Search this Article|