Originally Posted by BendtheBar
Guy on the right has much better legs, calves and forearms, much weaker shoulders and lats. Guy on the right has better biceps (by a hair). I think the guy on the right has a smaller waist and much better arm and leg aesthetics too.
So weighing these, for me I see the guy on the right with a lot more going for him, but very weak lats and shoulders.
From the backshot though, I felt his back looked much better than either of the other two.
I would have picked the guy on the right as well.